ARUN SHOURIE: The institutions are the persons who man them at that particular time Individual judges have changed the course of justice in the Supreme Court Institutions are not something abstract, they are the individuals who man them. For example, in Mr Vajpayees case, I found that his natural scepticism would bring out in you the contrary point of view. At least we have one professional. "If Anita has to be helped change her clothes, then focus only on that.". He has worked as an economist with the World Bank, a consultant to the Planning Commission of India, editor of the Indian Express and The Times of India and a Minister of Communications and Information Technology in the Vajpayee Ministry (1998-2004). He joined hands with Arun Shourie Indian Express chairman Ramnath Goenka for a crusade against Dhirubhai Ambani's Reliance Industries. (HarperCollins). [16][17] Shourie was a winner of the Ramon Magsaysay Award in 1982, in the Journalism, Literature and Creative Communication Arts category as "a concerned citizen employing his pen as an effective adversary of corruption, inequality and injustice. She and Adit were tossed inside the car. I was surprised, because I wasnt a party member. After BJP was defeated in the general elections of 2009, Arun Shourie asked for reflection and liability within the party. Those who build walls between people are the very demons of darkness. THE QUESTION THAT poses itself as you make your way through Arun Shourie's memoir, The Commissioner For Lost Causes, of his days as a journalistand the decided superstar he was in the 1980s, face of the fantastic stories of The Indian Express ranging from purchasing a girl and exposing slavery to bringing down a chief minister for corruptionis . Today, the RSS middle leadership has been completely co-opted by the government apparatus. Arun Shourie with his son Aditya at their residence. He has also been named International Editor of the Year Award and was awarded The Freedom to Publish Award. VANDITA MISHRA: In your book, one of the underlying themes is how one can turn adversity in their favour. But when you age, someone else will decide what you wear and where you go. ARUN SHOURIE: I did not want to suggest that, This has been going on for a long time, so what is surprising in it?. Thats true. You cant do it overnight. "Irrigators channel water; fletchers straighten arrows; carpenters fashion wood; the wise master their minds," he says. For reprint rights:Times Syndication Service. Parents of special needs children in India tend not to talk about them in public. These cracks provide a dangerous opportunity to political rulers to suborn this institution also.Through actual cases and judgmentsof subordinate courts, High Courts, the Supreme CourtArun Shourie enables us to see how frail and vulnerable this 'last pillar standing' has become. This was because the readers felt that it was not just their (the medias) voice which is being choked, my voice is being choked. Jha has blamed Shourie of misinterpreting his writings and making wrong accusation of plagiarism against him. A spout would help. Yet he laughs you can hear his laughter three houses away. Aditya looks at me and raises his left arm. Both are in ample evidence in this book.' - India Today In this incisive commentary, Arun Shourie documents the ways in which our history textbooks have been doctored by leftist historians. Modi said to me, When the bride goes from the maternal home to her husbands home, her gait, her speech, her clothes, her demeanour has to change. I thought he would do it., Does the Prime Minister share his economic views? Gradually, such children have become more visible in recent years.". He shared his life experiences in the 2011-book Does He Know a Mother's Heart: How Suffering Refutes Religion. And then I only crystallised that evidence. In his fathers words in his book Does He Know a Mothers Heart?, on religion and suffering, He cannot walk or stand. The First Chapter relates to Arun Shourie's bed ridden wife - Anita's case: of her trials and tribulations when she finds herself as an accused in a trial, for having constructed a farm-house in violation of environmental regulations. He cannot stand, he cannot use his right arm. [10] His sister is the journalist Nalini Singh. Arun Shourie. The. One is Gandhijis way he was immersed till his last breath. But, Arun, your wife is, all that notwithstanding, so very privileged because she has a husband like you. [11], He is skeptical of religions and especially the concept of organised religion. Copyright Bennett, Coleman & Co. Ltd. All rights reserved. This emboldens me to say one more thing. Can gay marriage be part of Hindu cultu Can gay marriage be part of Hindu culture? He was in turn criticised for what was perceived as a thinly-veiled attack on Islam itself, with Rafiq Zakaria, the Muslim scholar, saying that Shourie's concern for reform of Islam was in fact demonstrative of Hindu contempt that used the plight of Muslim women as an example of the backwardness of the community. He was awarded the Ramon Magsaysay Award in 1982 and the Padma Bhushan in 1990. It means that he wants it to be done fast, like the one who has a beard, Suman!, Does Arun Shourie mind being thought of as a maverick? If it is the same type of person, then you are not going to get contrary advice, Also Read |Laxmi Vilas hotel case: Arun Shourie furnishes personal bonds in CBI court, HC to hear case today, Have the Chinese gone back? I wish only to request you to be available to a whole world of people - the broken, bleeding humanity - who need you, a little more than you may otherwise realise. And they are swept away by the small little things an official car, being saluted There is a misperception today that Mr Modi is mindful of the RSS. I said once you are in Delhi you must take everyone together. Who can disagree with Arun here? Shourie, who held portfolios like disinvestment, commerce and industry and communications in the National Democratic Alliance (NDA) regime (1999-2004), has written at least 20 books, dealing with issues such as Indian law and polity, national security, religion, economics, and journalism. As they absorbed the news, the kind doctor gave them what Shourie calls the "best piece" of advice anyone could offer: "I have not been to your country but from what I have heard, you have strong, well-knit families there. But no one can feign to not know how prodigious your suffering is. During the Emergency he wrote statements for Jayaprakash Narayan, and in 1977 found his vocation as an investigative journalist and editor, only to divert to supporting the RSS and the Ram Janmabhoomi movement. Yet another was a keyboard to allow access to around 50 regularly visited websites on the internet. Then cabinet secretary Vinod Pandey had relied on his blind faith in astrology to run the country. Also Read: Nirmala Sitharaman interview: Fight us in House, attract smaller parties, keep us under watchbut Cong moving further to fringe. Focus on your reaction to that event. This is what happened in the judiciary. Both he, and later Shourie, regularly appealed to the courts as the forum for last appeal. [6] Arun Shourie speaks about his personal life and reviews his life events as case diaries "My writing is like the case diary of an advocate which is aimed at winning a case" and his opinions on journalism. "Why must we wait for the US to develop these things. The father shouts at the child, curses him. Wheelchair access in buildings is rare. Performance & security by Cloudflare. Some of his envious colleagues dubbed his writings more in the style of a pamphleteer or a lawyers brief than a newspaper article, but his aim was to make a watertight case. It is because suffering broke and expanded my soul (how else can the soul be expanded?) And internally, the country is grappling with the economy. Shourie says these two elderly couples devoted the rest of their lives to loving and raising Aditya, the "darling of the family". Ed Sheeran copyright trial: Why has the British singer-songwriter been sued? Every day I was carrying Anitas milk to him in a test tube.. We do anything but live as human beings. Syracuse University, Maxwell School of Citizenship and Public Affairs, Modern School, St. Stephen's College, Delhi, Falling Over Backwards,Self-Deception: India's China Policies,Does He Know A Mothers Heart. Well, there are things that money cannot buy. Shourie was spotted by Ramnath Goenka, the legendary founder of The Indian Express. Tell them the truth. Journalist, politician, and author Arun Shourie has worn many masks. This is true of defensive power. Obscenity over the Internet ? [1] He became a fellow of the Indian Council of Social Science Research in 1976. Well, there are things that money cannot buy. ANANT GOENKA: World over, more and more people are voting based on identity even at the cost of the economy and jobs. A byline and placement on the front page began to be determined by newsworthiness of the story and not on the basis of the seniority of those writing the piece, as was often the case. 08:30 am Author Arun Shourie. Mia Khalifa questions Priyanka Chopra's Mia Khalifa questions Priyanka Chopra's silence over farmers' protest. But, Arun, your wife is, all that notwithstanding, so very privileged because she has . The writer, once a hard-nosed journalist who was editor of both the Times of India and the Indian Express in the late 1980s, recalls moving to religion while rushing a frequently ailing Adit to hospital. I could not hold back my tears when I heard these words. Im absolutely astonished the Prime Minister would go so far just for one state election. Jha criticized Shourie's book Eminent Historians, which concerned the NCERT textbook controversies, that it contains "slander" and "has nothing to do with history. Im not looking for a job, a new wife, or a daughter-in-law.. And what are the short- and long-term reforms India must implement? D N Jha", "Votes do not guide intellectuals: D N Jha", "Arun Shourie hits out at BJP top leadership", "Arun Shourie at Idea Exchange: 'Everybody can be instigatedpeople haven't shifted, the lid has been lifted', Interview from December 2013 at rediff.com, https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Arun_Shourie&oldid=1146872061, This page was last edited on 27 March 2023, at 13:13. But the teaching is, at that time, dont focus on the event. Stay tuned for the latest in legislative updates, Op-eds by RahulsIAS team, Guest posts by legal experts on contemporary legal issues and vexed questions of law, latest case law, model answers and Interviews. [23] He has said that, although he sees a danger from perceived Muslim violence such as the Godhra train burning incident of 2002, people have tended to redefine the "Hindutva" term. SHUBHAJIT ROY: You mentioned how the government doesnt value expertise. His wife meanwhile refused to meet with spiritual gurus as her "hopes were raised again and again, and again and again they are shattered." But finally one day, Krishnamurti invited them to his. I think they may be voting against the alternative and not for the person. They have to be dealt with," Shourie says. Arun Shourie writes about bringing up his son Aditya, afflicted with cerebral palsy for many years now, in his new book, Does He know a mother's heart? How can we separate suffering from love? I wish you would share yourself with us more often. The way is to prepare for much greater violence in the future. We had meetings from around 6-11 pm, and during that time he would show total focus. [23], With the exception of Mahatma Gandhi, he has little time for any religious thinker and, says Nussbaum, his books "nowhere seek to provide balance; nowhere is there a sense of complexity. Not much is known about his family other than the fact that his father was a government employee. So we as citizens have to wake up in time. "Thirty years ago, people averted their eyes," says Shourie. But, in essential terms, you come through stronger. We watched in awe and delight as he trashed the concept that the editorial pronouncements by a few elite editors cooped up in their own tiny echo chambers was the soul of the newspaper. You, and not a politician or godman, represent us. Continue readingFor 24x7 updates on Mumbai and Maharashtra. While we are talking, Aditya Shourie appears in his wheelchair. Sorry, I forget the exact year; you would remember it. Thats the problem. So, this is the complete throwing away of all norms. I dont think I would have lasted 15 days if I had been inside the regime because there is a character to the regime. As a cabinet minister overseeing information and technology, Shourie campaigned on behalf of improved access for the disabled, efforts that were abandoned by his successors after he left office in 2004. But under the guise of free speech, nonsense is being spread. Create a free website or blog at WordPress.com. "[14] In 2000, he was named as one of the International Press Institute's World Press Freedom Heroes. Showing 30 distinct works. As he is a politician, writer, and journalist so his net worth depends upon his published book, a s sets etc. Answer Writing Exercise(CPC-1) Broad Guidelines for a Model Answer. He was later to return to India, where he would become a cabinet minister, prolific author and newspaper editor, who fought corruption and campaigned for press freedom during his time at The Indian Express and The Times of India. The money would go to a newly formed trust, the Indira Gandhi Pratibha Pratishthan. For a country that prides itself on its information technology industry, he is dismayed that so little attention is paid to improving accessibility, or offering simple gadgets that can improve the quality of life. If you had what (former US President Abraham) Lincoln called a team of rivals, then you would be hearing more. For dealing with life and what it sends us, the Buddha's position is the most helpful, the writer suggests. He knows hes the king. When Shourie asked her what purpose it could serve since Aditya was never going to use it, she replied: "But just see his sense of achievement when he gets the answer right.". "Buddha explains whether the world is finite or infinite or both; whether the Tathagata survives after death or notthere is birth, there is aging, there is death, there is sorrow, lamentation, pain, grief and despair. [6] He obtained his doctorate in Economics from the Maxwell School of Citizenship and Public Affairs at Syracuse University in 1966. Its a meaningless number. Devi Lal, as deputy PM, used the choicest abuses and threats against the newspaper for writing about his son (Om Prakash) Chautalas brazen ballot stuffing in the 1990 Meham by-election. I waited for six months before I spoke and till the evidence was in front of everybody. Things have been bad in the lower courts for a long time. Simultaneously, between 197274, he was a consultant to the Indian Planning Commission and it was around this time that he began writing articles as a journalist, criticizing economic policy. Some of the investigative series he either wrote or oversaw the prolonged detention of thousands of undertrials, the blinding of prisoners in Bihar to serve as a deterrent, the Kamala case which exposed trafficking of women, the scandal of the missing Kuo Oil deal file, the Antulay trusts and Bofors are landmarks in journalism history and public interest litigation. Nor have I, since then. He cannot use his right arm or hand. 'Curvy' mermaid statue causes stir in Southern Italy, I tried Asus ROG gaming laptop with a massive 18-inch display: Heres what I experienced, Justice for 'India's daughters' more important than Asian Games medal: Bajrang Punia, Jack Dorsey questions Elon Musks leadership at Twitter: It all went south, Garmin Forerunner 265 review: Get set for a good run, Michelle Obama and Kate Capshaw sing along with Bruce Springsteen on stage, Mumbai Police share video of people coming together to push a stranded bus, AI artist imagines top politicians as rockstars. The bubble of human self-sufficiency bursts. Before the Bihar elections, he described the NDA government as Congress plus a cow, and said that Prime Minister Modi was keeping silent on incidents like the Dadri killing while his colleagues stirred up trouble. But he speaks only syllable by syllable," Shourie, 69, says in his book. "[26], Historian D.N. But despite their style, the books are obviously the work of a brilliant man, with a wide if idiosyncratic learning, a passion for the freedoms of speech and press, and a desire to get beneath current events to address underlying issues. Suffering is intensely personal. There are several actions that could trigger this block including submitting a certain word or phrase, a SQL command or malformed data. Elma Smit Wiki, Age, Boyfriend, Husband, Family . Nor, he goes on, must parents fall into the trap of wondering when it will become easier, when the chores will end or when the demands placed on them will ease. They include perspective, as being sacked, receiving an award or promotion, or publishing another book is not of the slightest significance to Aditya. You can email the site owner to let them know you were blocked. He would meet and listen to all sorts of people. Immediately afterwards, he would tell the editor privately not to pay any heed to those objecting. And it takes 30 years to prepare. We had a very happy time in America, but my thoughts were elsewhere., As a consultant to the Planning Commission, he again blotted his copybook by pointing out that figures in the Third Five-year Plan had been falsified. Restoration work at Punes Sassoon hospital: Memorial of Mahatma Gandhis appendicitis surgery to get makeover, Alibabas Jack Ma turns up in Japan as college professor, NEET UG 2023: Tips to ace the toughest section Physics, Shah Rukh Khans son Aryan Khans directorial debut titled Stardom, deets here, Saina Nehwal to skip Asian Games trials due to fitness issues, Some Canadian workers in wage pact with govt to end strike from today, With middle-order under-performing, DC mull Axars batting number ahead of must-win game against GT, US regulator seizes First Republic Bank, to sell assets to JP Morgan, Scuffle over blocking view during IPL match at Arun Jaitley Stadium; no FIR, Anupam Kher recalls love story with Kirron Kher: She was MA first class, I was a simple village boy, Ramnath Goenka Excellence in Journalism Awards, Statutory provisions on reporting (sexual offenses), This website follows the DNPAs code of conduct. Aditya has been the centre of his universe for 40 years. He has got all provincial leaders and key persons in districts in his hands. I too belong to all who suffer and all who thirst for a touch of togetherness. Arun Shourie has written several books. Shouries sombre conclusion is that no religion can offer a satisfactory explanation. What to expect. He joined The Indian Express shortly after the Emergency; the highly stratified hierarchy of the newsroom was a very different place from when he left. We must continue to speak the truth to them irrespective of what is fashionable today. Hyundai's Creta EV spotted on another test run. His statue is one of the largest in the Parliament complex. Whether an order for further investigation u/s 173(8) CrPC can be passed post-cognizance ? Writing in a matter-of-fact tone almost as though he is taking notes and not even properly constructing sentences Shourie devotes the first part of the book to the double tragedy of his life, recounting how, 22 years ago, as they were coping with Aditya, Anita was diagnosed with Parkinsons Disease at the age of 42. He recognised his talent, drive and dedication, even as he sometimes wondered whether the racehorse he had hired would wreck his paper. Book reviews, festivals and all things literary. One idea was "text to voice" technology for the blind. [10] His sister is the journalist Nalini Singh. So what is absent today? Every six months you are giving a Rs 1 lakh crore figure and nothing happens. Shourie remains calm, avoiding the sort of rage, resentment and bitterness that can overcome parents with special needs children. Actually, there was no farm house and she was finally exonerated from all charges. Modi has the power of Jesus he raises the dead: the Congress Party, the leftist intellectuals., Shouries devil-may-care attitude towards the conventions of public life may be conditioned by his personal circumstances. Read 15 years of Mumbai Mirror's journalism here. Perceptions vary when seen from different angles and Shourie sometimes suffers from tunnel vision. And that capacity is lacking, because of the general weakening of the governmental system and its inability or unwillingness to be seen as harnessing the entrepreneurial and managerial talent in the private sector. Neither was available in India. On that occasion, you not only inaugurated the event with winsome dignity, but also moved the hearts of all delegates by the way you related to the leprosy-ravaged people who attended the meet. Cloudflare Ray ID: 7c06cbd72f5f3b50 There is a thin line between self-righteousness and being self-centred. Today, people shun, fearing the reaction of the PM or (Union Home Minister) Amit Shah. He speaks syllable by syllable. [25], Arun Shourie has written numerous books. [4][5], Arun Shourie was born in Jalandhar, British India, on 2 November 1941. I know this could sound insensitive, given how preoccupied you are with things at home. Shourie says that these gadgets make a big difference to people. After all, in Mr (PM Narendra) Modis case, he was not elected to continue, he was supposed to change things. Adit, he says, has a very high threshold of pain"He has taught himself to bear unbelievable amount of it," Shourie says. The Weight of Love. I have a son, who cannot speak." Arun talks about the helplessness that creeps upon us through ageing. P VAIDYANATHAN IYER: Externally, the country is grappling with China. Shourie and Maharashtra Times editor, Govind Talwalkar, began to investigate. One lakh of each sureties for Arun Shourie were his old colleague Jaswant Singh's son Manvendra Singh and his wife Chitra Singh. Shourie speaks fondly of his mother-in-law, Maltiji, who looked after Aditya for 25 years despite her crippling arthritis. One of the most moving passages in the book is the section where Shourie describes the lessons his son has taught him. The light of life begins to fade into the twilight of mere existence, which seems no more than an antechamber to the nothingness of death. he asks. My only claim in sharing these words with you is that I too have walked the via dolorosa of life. "If Adit has to be toileted, then focus only on lifting him out of bed and toileting him," he writes. The Indian Express website has been rated GREEN for its credibility and trustworthiness by Newsguard, a global service that rates news sources for their journalistic standards. Shourie has the anecdotal reasoning of Nirad Chaudhuri married to the writing style of Robert Ludlum. I thank my friend: PM Modi to Bill Gates for appreciating Mann Ki Baat. They were the readers Every time there was a raid on Ramnathjis house and on The Indian Express, the circulation went up. What kind of government says that we cannot pay compensation because we dont know how many migrants died? "Thats why I cant understand the way Indian families are portrayed in television soap operas the scheming mother-in-law and the devious daughter-in-law. They took his advice and returned to New Delhi. For instance, TN Seshan in the Election Commission, or Y V Reddy in the Reserve Bank of India. I dont feel Im a very deep person, he says in his soft voice, but I dont shrink from where the facts lead. His PhD was on the allocation of foreign exchange between ministries, and was a damning condemnation of the Indian system. (Express archive photo by Sunil Saxena 28.10.1995), Frenny and Other Women You Have Met: New book celebrates non-working women, their struggles, Vineet Gills Here and Hereafter is a deep dive into the pioneering work of Nirmal Verma, In A Resurgent Northeast Narratives of Change, bureaucrat Ashish Kundra offers a nuanced and forward-looking account of Northeast 2.0, A Parsi could belong to any religion or none: Coomi Kapoor, https://images.indianexpress.com/2020/08/1x1.png. Arun quotes Mother Teresa, "Love till it hurts". Then the night comes. "My wife cannot sign a cheque," Arun says with extreme candour. Copyright HT Digital Streams Ltd. All rights reserved. Independence does not mean being contrary. Sometimes, one doesnt need this exercise of emotional telepathy (or in other words, stepping into the litigants shoes). We are the majority. What led to the violence in Manipurs Churachandpur before CM N Biren Singhs visit? ARUN SHOURIE: The fact that they are voting in a particular way does not justify a particular criterion. If you see the falsehoods which have been uttered, I think they are exceeded only by (US President Donald) Trump. They keep their personal battles and emotional agonies private. [12] In his 2020-book Preparing for Death, he wrote about dealing with mortality, and added that others can approach this eventuality by looking at the examples of Ramakrishna Paramahamsa, Gautama Buddha, Ramana Maharshi, Mahatma Gandhi and Vinoba Bhave. It is not that the present regime is merely continuing what was happening earlier, it is accelerating the decline of one institution after the other. 12crore) of discretionary spending available to him under Members of Parliament Local Area Development Scheme (MPLADS) to setting up of Bio-Sciences & Bio-engineering Department at the Indian Institute of Technology Kanpur. Supreme Court can grant divorce on grounds of irretrievable breakdown o Centre blocks 14 mobile apps used by terrorists, their supporters in J&K. The appointment of Mr Jaishankar is a wonderful exception to the norm. That was, incidentally, what Jesus did. Before last years general election, he would prepare briefing papers for Narendra Modi and go to Ahmedabad to discuss them. But another personal loss accelerated the spiritual journey. It is the progressive decay over time of all institutions, starting with Parliament, the legislatures, bureaucracy, judiciary, and the media. When Indira Gandhi decided to take over his newspaper during the Emergency, he fought back fiercely. Nobody can know everything So to make it a practice to stay away from all expertise and push out anybody who is regarded as an expert, opens not just the regime but the country to great danger.
Repression In Jekyll And Hyde, Sprained Hand Still Hurts After 2 Weeks, Articles A